Acoustic Guitar Pickup Ratings: Top Picks & Fair Reviews
The melodic tones of an acoustic guitar are as varied as the rich textures of the wood that makes them. But what turns an acoustic guitar into a workhorse of a performance instrument? The pickups, of course. These handy devices convert the guitar's vibrations into electrical signals, amplifying its sound, and allowing it to thrive in a wide range of settings. Let's dive into the world of acoustic guitar pickup ratings to help you make an informed decision.
Before we delve into specific models, it's crucial to understand the types of acoustic guitar pickups. The three primary types are traditional magnetic pickups, piezoelectric pickups, and blended systems. Each has its strengths and weaknesses, which we'll explore shortly.
Traditional Magnetic Pickups
Magnetic pickups, often seen in electric guitars, work by detecting the metal strings' vibrations with magnets. For acoustic guitars, these are typically undersaddle pickups, which sit under the saddle, sensing vibrations directly from the bridge.
Magnetic pickups capture a more electric guitar-like tone, which is ideal for players who want to mimic an electric sound on their acoustic. However, they can struggle with the full dynamic range and complex timbre of an acoustic guitar.
Seymour Duncan Mini Acoustic
The Seymour Duncan Mini Acoustic is a popular choice for its clarity and ability to capture the authentic acoustic tone. Despite being a magnetic pickup, it maintains a warm, natural sound, making it a favorite among acoustic players.
It's also pedal-friendly, allowing for creative sound manipulation. However, it may not capture the full frequency range as well as a piezo pickup.
Fishman Rare Earth
The Fishman Rare Earth is another excellent magnetic pickup, known for its dynamic range and capacity to capture the guitar's natural resonance. It's praised for its organic tone and minimal noise, providing both warmth and clarity.
It's also versatile, accommodating various playing styles and tonal preferences. Despite its strengths, it may not cater to those seeking a more amplified, electric sound.
Piezoelectric Pickups
Piezo pickups, like those made by companies like Fishman and LR Baggs, use a crystal that converts pressure changes (from the guitar's vibrations) into electrical signals. They excel at capturing the full dynamics and wide frequency range of an acoustic guitar.
However, they can sound overly harsh or quacky without proper EQ and tweaking, and they don't capture astringent, airy tones as well as magnetic pickups.
Fishman Ellipse ASolo
The Fishman Ellipse ASolo is a widelyUsed piezo pickup system, lauded for its mimicking an electric sound on their warm, rich tone. It's highly versatile, with multiple voicing options and easy-to-use controls.
Its Active EQ preamp also helps shape your sound, taming unwarranted frequencies and enhancing desirable ones.
LR Baggs VTC-5a
The LR Baggs VTC-5a is a step above, offering studio-quality tone and versatility. It uses a proprietary Element pickup, providing an incredibly dynamic and balanced response.
It's also pedal-friendly, has a class A MOSFET preamp for high headroom, and comes with a built-in tuner. However, its price tag reflects its premium features.
Blended Systems
Blended systems combine the best of both worlds, using a magnetic pickup and a piezo pickup together. They capture the full range of your guitar's sound, from low-frequency resonance to high, delicate notes.
However, they can be complex to set up and may require more tweaking to find your desired tone, striking a balance between warmth and clarity.
Fishman Ellipse Aura
The Fishman Ellipse Aura is a popular blended system, using Fishman's imaging technology to layer a studio-mic'd grand piano sound with your guitar's pickup signal. This creates a rich, lush tone with amazing dynamic range.
It's versatile, with multiple voicing options and a convenient, easy-to-use preamp. However, it might be too expensive for budget-conscious players.
Shadow acrylic Strat-o-Mic
The Shadow acrylic Strat-o-Mic is another blended system, providing a unique combination of piezo and magnetic pickups. It's praised for its authentic acoustic tone and full frequency response.
It's also unique in its installation, using an acrylic saddle to pick up vibrations from the bridge. However, it may not be compatible with every guitar due to its specific installation process.
At the end of the day, the best acoustic guitar pickup depends on your specific needs, playing style, and budget. Consider your desired tone, the complexity you're willing to deal with, and the durability each model offers. The world of acoustic guitar pickup ratings is vast and varied, but with the right information, you're sure to find the perfect fit for your guitar.