▲Wirig Diagram Hot
▲ ▲ ▼

Are All Electrical Conductors Good Thermal Conductors?

By

Conductors are materials capable of transmitting electricity. Some are also adept at transmitting heat, but not all electrical conductors are equally efficient thermal conductors. The two phenomena, while related, aren't linearly connected.

Let's explore this concept by examining the differences between electrical and thermal conductivity, and then we'll delve into specific materials to illustrate this point.

Understanding Electrical and Thermal Conductivity

Electrical conductivity is a measure of a material's ability to conduct an electric current. It's primarily influenced by the number of free electrons in a material and their mobility. Conversely, thermal conductivity measures how efficiently a material can transmit heat.

the poster is written in different colors and sizes, including words that describe what they are doing
the poster is written in different colors and sizes, including words that describe what they are doing
Conductor vs Insulator
Conductor vs Insulator
Electrical Conductors Insulator Physical Vector Illustration Stock Vector (Royalty Free) 1571334199 | Shutterstock
Electrical Conductors Insulator Physical Vector Illustration Stock Vector (Royalty Free) 1571334199 | Shutterstock

While both phenomena involve movement of particles, electrical conductivity deals with charged particles (electrons and ions), while thermal conductivity involves movement of phonons (quasiparticles responsible for transporting heat).

Free Electrons vs. Electron Mobility

Materials with many free electrons are generally good electrical conductors. However, thermal conductivity isn't solely determined by the number of electrons. It also depends on how freely these electrons can move within the material's lattice structure.

Electrical Conductors and Insulators Anchor Chart
Electrical Conductors and Insulators Anchor Chart
10 Powerful Facts About the Importance of Good and Bad Conductors of Heat in 2026 | Science online
10 Powerful Facts About the Importance of Good and Bad Conductors of Heat in 2026 | Science online
Printable Conductors and Insulators Teaching Resources
Printable Conductors and Insulators Teaching Resources

In some materials, while there might be plenty of electrons, their mobility might be restricted due to strong electron-phonon interactions, which hinder their ability to carry heat effectively. Thus, high electrical conductivity doesn't always translate to high thermal conductivity.

The Role of Phonons

Phonons, which are quanta of vibrational energy, play a significant role in thermal conductivity. Materials where phonons can travel far without scattering (like in perfect crystals) tend to have high thermal conductivities. Conversely, introducing lattice defects (like in amorphous materials) can limit phonon travel, reducing thermal conductivity.

Even if a material has a high density of free electrons (making it a good electrical conductor), its thermal conductivity can still be low if phonon travel is impeded,either due to strong electron-phonon interactions or due to the presence of phonon-scattering lattice defects.

Conductors and Insulators Anchor Chart
Conductors and Insulators Anchor Chart
the differences between conductors and insulators are shown in this graphic above it is an image of electrical equipment
the differences between conductors and insulators are shown in this graphic above it is an image of electrical equipment
Conductors And Insulators Worksheet
Conductors And Insulators Worksheet
two diagrams that show how to conduct an electrical device
two diagrams that show how to conduct an electrical device
10 Powerful Facts About the Importance of Good and Bad Conductors of Heat in 2026 | Science online
10 Powerful Facts About the Importance of Good and Bad Conductors of Heat in 2026 | Science online
an image of two wires labeled in the following words, conductor and insulator wire
an image of two wires labeled in the following words, conductor and insulator wire

Case Studies: Materials with Divergent Thermal and Electrical Conductivities

To further illustrate this point, let's examine a few materials with high electrical conductivity but low thermal conductivity, and vise versa.

One such material is Titanium Dioxide (TiO2). Despite having a high electrical band gap which inhibits electrical conductivity, the low phonon velocity and short phonon mean free path result in poor thermal conductivity (around 4.5 W/(m*K) at room temperature).

Graphene: High Electrical, Low Thermal Conductivity

Graphene, a one-atom-thick layer of carbon, is a prime example of a material with high electrical conductivity (around 50,000 S/m for pristine graphene) but low thermal conductivity when confined to thin layers. Its low thermal conductivity is due to strong electron-phonon interactions and dimensional constraints.

Graphene's high electrical conductivity comes from the pi-bands formed by electrons in the honeycomb crystal lattice, but these same electrons scatter phonons effectively, reducing its thermal conductivity.

Silver: High Thermal, Moderate Electrical Conductivity

Silver, on the other hand, is known for its excellent thermal conductivity (around 429 W/(m*K) at room temperature), despite being a good electrical conductor. This is because its high density of free electrons facilitates efficient phonon transmission. However, its electrical conductivity is not particularly high, especially compared to metals like copper or gold.

Silver's relatively smaller electrical conductivity (6.3x10^7 S/m) compared to its thermal conductivity stems from the complex interplay between its electronic and phononic properties and the ways in which electrons and phonons interact within its crystalline structure.

In essence, while there's some correlation between electrical and thermal conductivity, they're distinct properties governed by different phenomena. Thus, it's inaccurate to assume all good electrical conductors are also good thermal conductors. This understanding has significant implications in fields like electronics cooling, thermoelectric materials science, and energy storage.

💬 Comments ↗ Share ★ Save
AD