▲Wirig Diagram Hot
▲ ▲ ▼

Can Referees Review First Yellow Cards?

By

In the world of soccer, a yellow card is a disciplinary sanction used by referees to caution players for various offenses. The rules governing the issuance of yellow cards are clearly defined in the Laws of the Game. But can a player receive a second yellow card in the same match for a similar offense? The short answer is yes, let's delve into the details.

In soccer, referees can indeed issue a second yellow card to a player who commits a similar, but separate, cautionable offense after receiving the first one. This is often referred to as a 'double caution' leading to a 'yellow double' or even a 'yellow red', where the player essentially receives a red card for a second caution.

Understanding the Laws of the Game

The rules governing yellow cards are outlined in Law 12 of the IFAB (International Football Association Board) Laws of the Game. It states that a player is cautioned, and a yellow card is shown, when they commit certain misconduct offenses, such as delaying the restart of play, dissent, or entering, re-entering, or deliberately leaving the field of play without the referee's permission.

a referee is holding up his yellow card
a referee is holding up his yellow card
a man holding up a yellow card in front of his face while standing on the grass
a man holding up a yellow card in front of his face while standing on the grass
referee showing yellow card to soccer player on field
referee showing yellow card to soccer player on field

While the specific offenses that warrant a yellow card can vary, the key point here is that a second cautions leading to a send-off for a second cautionable offense during the same match is allowed and happens frequently in the sport.

When Does the 'Double Caution' Apply?

Since a player can commit a separate cautionable offense, a referee may show the player a second yellow card, followed by a red card, for distinct misconducts. For instance, a player could receive a first yellow for dissent and a second one for time-wasting, resulting in their dismissal from the game.

the referee is holding his yellow card in one hand and pointing to it with both hands
the referee is holding his yellow card in one hand and pointing to it with both hands
Yellow Card In Soccer (Official Rules)
Yellow Card In Soccer (Official Rules)
Game-Changing VAR Update: Yellow Cards to be Reviewed for the First Time at the World Cup! - Flying Eze
Game-Changing VAR Update: Yellow Cards to be Reviewed for the First Time at the World Cup! - Flying Eze

It's crucial to understand that this is treated as two separate cautions, not a single cumulative offense. The offenses must be distinct; for example, a player cannot be given a 'double caution' for repeated instances of the exact same offense, like many instances of foul play in quick succession.

Appeals and Subsequent Matches

While players cannot appeal yellow cards, they can appeal straight red cards (including those resulting from a 'double caution'). The appeal process varies by league and country but generally involves a review of the incident by an independent disciplinary committee.

Subsequent matches are not affected by previous yellow cards, only by red cards. The Laws of the Game reset the yellow card accumulation process for each match, meaning a player cannot carry over yellow cards from one game to the next, but they can receive multiple in a single match.

a person holding up a yellow card in the air with their right hand on it
a person holding up a yellow card in the air with their right hand on it
a referee is holding his yellow card in the air
a referee is holding his yellow card in the air
Vitinha Yellow card
Vitinha Yellow card
Howard Webb issues 14 yellow cards and a red in World Cup final
Howard Webb issues 14 yellow cards and a red in World Cup final
a man standing in front of a tv screen
a man standing in front of a tv screen
a referee is holding up his yellow card
a referee is holding up his yellow card

Red Cards and Suspensions

If a player is given a red card, they are shown the red card signal and ordered off the field. A one-match suspension typically follows, although the procedures and penalties may vary depending on the league's regulations.

A player cannot receive a 'double caution' in subsequent matches due to carryover yellow cards. Each match starts with a clean slate in terms of cautions and dismissals, although a red card suspension will still be in effect from previous games if applicable.

In summary, referees indeed have the authority to review and issue a first yellow card and subsequently a second yellow card (resulting in a red card) for distinct, separate offenses during the same match. The Laws of the Game are designed to maintain order and fair play, ensuring that players are held accountable for their actions on the field.

A Guide to Yellow and Red Cards in Soccer | SOCCER.COM
A Guide to Yellow and Red Cards in Soccer | SOCCER.COM
referee giving yellow card to soccer player on field with crowd in background during match play
referee giving yellow card to soccer player on field with crowd in background during match play
💬 Comments ↗ Share ★ Save
AD