▲Wirig Diagram Hot
▲ ▲ ▼

CMU Wall Rating: Top Picks & Comparison in 2023

By

The Carnegie Mellon University (CMU) Wall Rating, developed by the university's School of Architecture, is a controversial yet thought-provoking system that ranks the architectural merit of the university's buildings. This unique rating system has sparked discussions about the role of architecture in campus life and has captivated students, alumni, and academia alike.

The CMU Wall Rating was initiated in 2005 as a tongue-in-cheek reaction to the standard building rating systems, which often focus on technical and environmental factors while ignoring aesthetic and cultural impacts. By applying a grading scale to CMU's buildings based on their architectural significance, the system aims to foster a greater appreciation for campus architecture and to stimulate dialogue about the university's built environment.

The Metrics of the CMU Wall Rating

The CMU Wall Rating assesses buildings on three primary metrics:

CMU vs Precast Walls Comparison
CMU vs Precast Walls Comparison
the exterior wall type is 15a composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite
the exterior wall type is 15a composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite composite
Home
Home

  • History: This metric evaluates the building's historical significance, its architect, and any notable past residents or events that occurred within its walls.
  • Appearance: The building's exterior design and aesthetics are scrutinized, with points awarded for visually striking features and architectural innovation.
  • Atmosphere: This metric considers the building's internal environment, including its hopes, dreams, and the spirits of past occupants that allegedly linger within its walls.

Concrete Wall - CMU, Drywall, Wood Studs
Concrete Wall - CMU, Drywall, Wood Studs
What Is a CMU Wall? — Hunker
What Is a CMU Wall? — Hunker
CMU Walls: Advantages, Disadvantages and A Better Option
CMU Walls: Advantages, Disadvantages and A Better Option

The History Metric

Buildings like Hurt locker (now referred to as Gates-Hillman Complex) and Porter Hall, designed by renowned architect Frank Lloyd Wright, score highly on the history metric due to their historical significance and the esteemed architects responsible for their designs.

Even newer structures like the Cohon University Center and the Tepper Quad, designed by world-class architectural firms, earn points for their innovative designs and the renowned architects behind them, demonstrating that historical significance isn't limited to older buildings.

The Appearance Metric

The Foster optimism (Wean Hall) and the Gregorian phrase (Baker Hall) exemplify exceptional architectural design and score high on the appearance metric. Their visually striking features and innovative design elements captivate students and visitors, making them iconic campus landmarks.

a diagram showing the width of a wall with different sections labeled in black and white
a diagram showing the width of a wall with different sections labeled in black and white
an architectural drawing showing the details for a metal stair casement with measurements and description
an architectural drawing showing the details for a metal stair casement with measurements and description
CMU control joints
CMU control joints
What Is CMU Wall | Advantages & Disadvantages of CMU Walls | Applications of Concrete Masonry Unit
What Is CMU Wall | Advantages & Disadvantages of CMU Walls | Applications of Concrete Masonry Unit
Deepwater House, Mount Pleasant WA — AHA Studio
Deepwater House, Mount Pleasant WA — AHA Studio
Unveiling the CMU Wall: Discover the History Behind Carnegie Mellon University!
Unveiling the CMU Wall: Discover the History Behind Carnegie Mellon University!

Meanwhile, newer buildings like the Tepper Quad and the Purnell Center for the Arts showcase modern architectural trends, earning points for their contemporary designs and cutting-edge materials, despite not yet having accumulated historical significance.

The Debates Surrounding the CMU Wall Rating

The CMU Wall Rating has sparked lively debates and commentary, with proponents arguing that it encourages students to engage with and appreciate their campus architecture, while detractors contend that it oversimplifies and trivializes architectural criticism.

Critics also argue that the system privileges pedigree and appearances over functionality and sustainability, a concern shared by many in the architectural community.

Woven in stone: The role of CMUs in architectural design
Woven in stone: The role of CMUs in architectural design
What is a Concrete Masonry Unit (CMU)? | CMU Wall Meaning
What is a Concrete Masonry Unit (CMU)? | CMU Wall Meaning

Academic Reactions to the CMU Wall Rating

Architecture professors at CMU and other universities have used the CMU Wall Rating as a teaching tool, encouraging students to think critically about architecture and its role in shaping campus culture. Students are tasked with evaluating buildings based on the CMU Wall Rating criteria and defending their assessments, fostering a deeper understanding of architecture's multifaceted impact.

Moreover, the CMU Wall Rating has inspired academic research and conferences, with scholars exploring the intersection of architecture, identity, and culture, and the potential for alternative rating systems to reshape how we think about and appreciate our built environments.

CampusResponse to the CMU Wall Rating

Students, faculty, and staff have embraced the CMU Wall Rating, with many proudly displaying their building's scores on their residence hall doors. The competition among residence halls to achieve the highest rating has fostered a sense of pride and camaraderie, with buildings banding together to petition for higher scores and challenge the system's criteria.

CMU's Office of Campus Design and Facility Management has also used the CMU Wall Rating to inform decisions about campus development, seeking to balance the need for practicality and sustainability with the aspirational aims of the rating system.

The CMU Wall Rating continues to evolve, sparking conversation and controversy as it challenges traditional approaches to architectural criticism. Whether you find the system whimsical or substantive, one thing is clear: the CMU Wall Rating has left an indelible mark on campus culture and has encouraged a richer, more dynamic engagement with CMU's built environment.

💬 Comments ↗ Share ★ Save
AD