Is Bioshock: Burial at Sea Canon?
The "BioShock" series, developed by Irrational Games and published by 2K Games, is renowned for its intricate storylines and atmospheric gameplay. One of the more divisive aspects among fans is the canonical status of "BioShock: Burial at Sea," a downloadable content (DLC) pack for "BioShock Infinite." Let's delve into the intricacies of this debate and explore the evidence, both for and against its canonicity.
Before we dive in, it's essential to understand that the canonicity of a video game element is typically determined by its acknowledgment and integration within the broader narrative by the developers and the subsequent installments in the series. With that in mind, let's investigate whether "Burial at Sea" is indeed canon.
Ken Levine's Stance
Ken Levine, the creative director of the "BioShock" series and the mastermind behind "Infinite" and its DLCs, has been notably vague about the canonicity of "Burial at Sea." In interviews, he has neither confirmed nor directly denied its status, leaving the matter open to interpretation.
In a Reddit AMA, Levine stated, "I don't want to discuss BioShock Infinite's DLC much beyond what we've said publicly," when asked about the canonicity of "Burial at Sea." This ambiguity has fueled the debate, with fans often interpreting his silence as an indication that the DLC is non-canon.
Lack of Acknowledgment in "BioShock 4" Rumors
One piece of evidence frequently cited by those who argue against "Burial at Sea's" canonicity is the lack of acknowledgment of its events in the rumored "BioShock 4." Supposedly in development by Ghost Story Games (a studio founded by Levine), no direct connections have been drawn between the rumored sequel and "Burial at Sea."
However, it's essential to consider that the development of "BioShock 4" is still unconfirmed, and any potential link to "Burial at Sea" would be purely speculative at this stage.
Story Overlap and Themes
Proponents of "Burial at Sea's" canonicity point to the shared story elements and themes with the main "BioShock" series. The DLC introduces Sofia Lamb, a prominent figure in the original "BioShock" who not only shares the same voice actor but also ties into the central themes of Objectivism and collectivism that have defined the series.
Moreover, the DLC's narrative explores the underwater city of Rapture, providing additional context and lore that supplements and enriches the original game's story. Some fans argue that this integration and expansion of the "BioShock" narrative are indicative of its canonicity.
"Burial at Sea" as a 'What-If' Scenario
An alternative interpretation of "Burial at Sea" is that it exists as a separate, parallel universe or an alternate timeline within the "BioShock" multiverse. This perspective suggests that while the events of "Burial at Sea" may not have directly impacted the main narrative, they still contribute to the broader lore and themes of the series.
This line of reasoning is supported by the fact that "Burial at Sea" does not directly contradict any of the established "BioShock" canon. Instead, it offers a different perspective on the same story, much like a "what-if" scenario. This interpretation allows "Burial at Sea" to exist within the "BioShock" universe without fundamentally altering the narrative established in the main games.
Delusions of Elizabeth and the Lutece twins
One piece of evidence that supports this perspective is the presence of Elizabeth, the protagonist of "BioShock Infinite," in "Burial at Sea." Elizabeth's presence in the DLC can be explained as a delusion induced by Festus, the Sea-Slug, which can also create doors to other dimensions. This explanation aligns with the genre-bending, reality-warping nature of the "BioShock" series and allows for Elizabeth's appearance without directly incorporating the events of "Burial at Sea" into the main series' timeline.
The Lutece twins, who also appear in both "BioShock Infinite" and "Burial at Sea," can be seen as further evidence of the multiverse interpretation. Their existence and behavior in the DLC can be explained as variants from an alternate timeline, rather than direct contradictions to their established characters in the main series.
Ultimately, the canonicity of "BioShock: Burial at Sea" may remain an unsettled debate among fans, given the lack of concrete confirmation from the developers. While some argue for its inclusion in the main series' narrative, others find compelling evidence to support its status as a separate, tangential story within the "BioShock" multiverse. Regardless of its official standing, "Burial at Sea" has undoubtedly left its mark on the series, enriching its lore and offering players a unique, thought-provoking experience. As the "BioShock" series continues to evolve and grow, fans eagerly await any potential developments that may finally shed light on this enduring mystery.