Diamond vs Graphite: thermal conductivity comparison
When comparing the thermal conductivity of diamond and graphite, a question that often comes up is: which is the better thermal conductor? Let's delve into this interesting comparison to find out.
Despite both being forms of carbon, diamond and graphite exhibit contrasting thermal conductivity values due to their distinct atomic structures. So, what makes them differ in this regard?
Understanding Thermal Conductivity
Thermal conductivity, a crucial material property, measures the heat transfer through a material per unit area per unit of temperature gradient per unit of time. It essentially tells us how well a material can conduct heat.
Given that diamond and graphite are composed of the same element, their difference in thermal conductivity lies squarely in their unique crystal structures.
Diamond Structure
Diamond, the harder of the two, boasts a tetrahedral covalent structure. Each carbon atom bonds with four others, forming a three-dimensional lattice with strong bonds. This robust structure allows efficient heat transfer, facilitating the movement of phonons (quasi-particles responsible for transporting heat).
Moreover, diamond's narrow band gap (5.45 eV) contributes to its superior electrical conductivity, further aiding in heat dissemination. As a result, diamond exhibits high thermal conductivity, approximately 1200-2300 W/(m·K).
Graphite Structure
Graphite, on the other hand, comprises layered sheets of atoms bound together by weak van der Waals forces. While the bonds within each sheet (covalent) are robust, the inter-layer bonds are not, leading to limited interactions between the layers.
Consequently, phonons struggle to move freely across layers, hindering heat transfer in the direction perpendicular to the layers (c-axis). Thus, while graphite has high in-plane thermal conductivity (around 180-200 W/(m·K)), its through-plane thermal conductivity is significantly lower, around 5-10 W/(m·K).
Thermal Conductivity Comparison
Comparing the two, diamond's thermal conductivity is clearly higher than that of graphite, particularly in the through-plane direction. In fact, diamond's thermal conductivity is roughly 60-230 times higher than graphite's in the basal plane (in the advanced measured state).
This difference makes diamond an exceptional choice for high-efficiency heat dissipation in applications like semiconductor manufacturing and power electronics, while graphite's anisotropic properties make it valuable in Bacon-Graphite-Rectifier cells for thermoelectric applications.
Anisotropy in Graphite
Graphite's anisotropic thermal conductivity hints at a potential workaround. By manipulating graphite's structure to align the basal planes along the through-plane direction, its thermal conductivity in that direction could be increased.
For instance, the use of macro fibrous graphites or graphene NYC ( navycompact graphites) can enhance the through-plane thermal conductivity by several folds, thereby narrowing the sizeable gap between graphite and diamond's thermal conductivity.
In conclusion, while diamond reigns supreme as a thermal conductor, the unique anisotropic properties of graphite open avenues for tailored heat transfer applications. The choice between the two largely depends on the specific needs and constraints of the intended application.