What is Blue Ocean vs Red Ocean Strategy?
The business landscape is fraught with competition, a situation aptly described by strategy expert W. Chan Kim and Renée Mauborgne as the 'red ocean'. Here, companies fight for market share in saturated spaces, knives sharpened and waves churned crimson with blood. But what if there was another way?
The 'blue ocean strategy', introduced by Kim and Mauborgne, deviates from the traditional competitive landscape. It's an approach that seeks out unpolluted waters, creating new markets and rendering rivals obsolete. But what exactly does blue ocean strategy entail, and how does it differ from its crimson cousin? Let's dive in.
Understanding Blue Ocean Strategy
In essence, blue ocean strategy is about creating uncontested market space, rendering rivals obsolete. It's about focusing on the 'Value Innovation' matrix, a framework that suggests you simultaneously deliver high value to customers and low cost to the company. It's like finding a hidden treasure on an unexplored island - it takes courage to leave the familiar shore, but the reward is often substantial.
To illustrate the blue ocean concept, consider Cirque du Soleil. It didn't try to compete with traditional circuses; instead, it created a 'blue ocean' by focusing on unique storytelling, sophisticated acrobatics, and a refined atmosphere. It made the competition irrelevant.
Value Innovation
At the heart of blue ocean strategy lies value innovation. It's not just about innovative products; it's about innovative value. Companies need to ask two key questions: which factors in our industry should be eliminated? Which factors should be reduced well below the industry standard? Which factors should be raised well above the industry standard? And which factors should be created that the industry has never offered?
Take Southwest Airlines. It didn't just eliminate or reduce factors like first-class seating and hub-and-spoke routing; it also created value by offering no-frill, point-to-point flights, and asking customers to assist with luggage handling. These innovations allowed it to provide substantially lower costs and higher value to customers, creating a 'blue ocean'.
Strategic Sequencing
Once a company identifies its 'blue ocean, it needs to chart a strategic sequence for its creation and capture. This involves deciding on the initial move, establishing momentum, supporting moves, and building distinctive organization capabilities.
For example, Dell's direct-to-customer business model was its initial move. This offered greater value to customers and lower costs for Dell. Building Online Ordering Systems and Customer Service Centers were key support moves that established further differentiation and minimized vulnerability to new entrants.
Red Ocean Strategy: The Traditional Approach
Red ocean strategy, in contrast, operates within existing market boundaries. It focuses on competing with rivals, raising barriers to entry, and protecting market share. It's about fighting for dominance in waters filled with sharks. And it's tough.riert approach,
Consider the steel industry. By focusing on low-cost competitors and cost reduction measures, companies ended up in a 'bloodier', more competitive 'red ocean'. Prices plummeted, and companies fought ruthlessly for survival.
Competitive Strategies
Red ocean strategies typically involve one of three competitive strategies: lowest cost, differentiation, or focus. Companies choose one (or some combination) and stick to it, aiming to be the undisputed leader in their chosen market segment.
The airline industry is a classic example. Delta Airlines' cost leadership strategy helps it consistently offer the lowest fares, while Emirates Airline differentiates itself through superior service and amenities.
Strategic Sequencing
After choosing a competitive strategy, companies must decide on the sequence of strategic moves. This could involve building or defending market share, increasing switching costs, or reducing costs.
For instance, after choosing a differentiation strategy, Starbucks sequentially established strong customer loyalty programs, created unique in-store experiences, and continuously innovated its product offerings to maintain its competitive advantage.
However, in a dynamic business environment, there's a risk of the 'red ocean' turning into a 'pink ocean' - where businesses lose profits while fighting each other or lose out to new entrants. Therefore, even for companies operating in traditional 'red oceans', periodically searching for 'blue oceans' can provide a much-needed competitive edge.
In the end, the choice between 'blue ocean' and 'red ocean' strategies isn't binary. They're different approaches suited to different situations. The key is to know when to fight and when to create - when to dive into the 'red ocean' and when to seek the untapped depths of the 'blue'.