▲Wirig Diagram Hot
▲ ▲ ▼

Why Barium Carbonate Refuses to Dissolve in Water

By

Why doesn't barium carbonate dissolve in water, unlike many other substances? This question might seem simple, but it's actually quite fascinating and rooted in the chemistry of barium carbonate. Let's delve into the reasons behind this fascinating insolubility.

Barium carbonate, a compound with the formula BaCO3, is a type of salt. Most salts, when placed in water, dissociate into their individual ions - a process known as solvation. Barium carbonate, however, behaves differently. It forms what is known as an insoluble salt, which doesn't break down in water. But why?

The Nature of Barium Carbonate

Barium carbonate is a high molecular weight compound, weighing in at approximately 197.34 g/mol. This alone makes it less soluble than lower molecular weight salts. However, this isn't the whole story. To truly understand why barium carbonate is insoluble in water, we need to delve deeper into its chemical properties.

the element baurium is shown in this poster
the element baurium is shown in this poster
Common Drinking Water Contaminants | Water Filter Guru
Common Drinking Water Contaminants | Water Filter Guru
Fun Science Kits & Experiments for Kids
Fun Science Kits & Experiments for Kids

The insolubility of barium carbonate is largely attributed to two factors: the large size of the barium ion (Ba^2+) and the nature of the carbonate ion (CO3^2-).

The Size of the Barium Ion

The barium ion is relatively large due to its two positive charges, which cause it to attract electrons nearer to the nucleus. This results in a smaller effective nuclear size, making the barium ion more polarizing. This polarization pulls the water molecules apart, making it energetically unfavourable for barium carbonate to dissolve in water.

a water dispenser next to a bottle of water with the caption is carbonated water acidic? here's the truth
a water dispenser next to a bottle of water with the caption is carbonated water acidic? here's the truth
Chemistry - JUST REWIND THE MAIN BASICS IN CHEMISTRY : Solubility Rules and Identifying a Precipitate 1. Alkali metal (Group IA) compounds are soluble. 2. Ammonium (NH4+) compounds are soluble. 3. Nitrates (NO3-), chlorates (ClO3-), and perchlorates (ClO4-) are soluble. 4. Most hydroxides (OH-) are insoluble. The exceptions are the alkali metal hydroxides and Ba(OH)2. Ca(OH)2 is slightly soluble. 5. Most chlorides (Cl-), bromides (Br-) or iodides (I-) are soluble. The exceptions are those containing Ag+, Hg+2, and Pb+2. 6. Carbonates (CO3-2), phosphates (PO4-3) and sulfides (S-2) are insoluble. The exceptions are the alkali metals and the ammonium ion. 7. Most sulfates (SO4-2) are soluble. CaSO4 and Ag2SO4 are slightly soluble. BaSO4, HgSO4 and PbSO4 are insoluble. An Example of Identifying a Precipitate A solution of barium chloride is mixed with a solution of potassium sulfate and a precipitate forms. Write the reaction and identify the precipitate. Barium chloride and potassium sulfate are both ionic compounds. We would expect them to undergo a double displacement reaction with each other. BaCl2 + K2SO4 BaSO4 + 2 KCl By examining the solubility rules we see that, while most sulfates are soluble, barium sulfate is not. Because it is insoluble in water we know that it is the precipitate. As all of the other substances are soluble in water we can rewrite the equation. BaCl2(aq) + K2SO4(aq) BaSO4(s) + 2 KCl(aq) | Facebook
Chemistry - JUST REWIND THE MAIN BASICS IN CHEMISTRY : Solubility Rules and Identifying a Precipitate 1. Alkali metal (Group IA) compounds are soluble. 2. Ammonium (NH4+) compounds are soluble. 3. Nitrates (NO3-), chlorates (ClO3-), and perchlorates (ClO4-) are soluble. 4. Most hydroxides (OH-) are insoluble. The exceptions are the alkali metal hydroxides and Ba(OH)2. Ca(OH)2 is slightly soluble. 5. Most chlorides (Cl-), bromides (Br-) or iodides (I-) are soluble. The exceptions are those containing Ag+, Hg+2, and Pb+2. 6. Carbonates (CO3-2), phosphates (PO4-3) and sulfides (S-2) are insoluble. The exceptions are the alkali metals and the ammonium ion. 7. Most sulfates (SO4-2) are soluble. CaSO4 and Ag2SO4 are slightly soluble. BaSO4, HgSO4 and PbSO4 are insoluble. An Example of Identifying a Precipitate A solution of barium chloride is mixed with a solution of potassium sulfate and a precipitate forms. Write the reaction and identify the precipitate. Barium chloride and potassium sulfate are both ionic compounds. We would expect them to undergo a double displacement reaction with each other. BaCl2 + K2SO4 BaSO4 + 2 KCl By examining the solubility rules we see that, while most sulfates are soluble, barium sulfate is not. Because it is insoluble in water we know that it is the precipitate. As all of the other substances are soluble in water we can rewrite the equation. BaCl2(aq) + K2SO4(aq) BaSO4(s) + 2 KCl(aq) | Facebook
a beakle full of water sitting next to a container with liquid in it on a table
a beakle full of water sitting next to a container with liquid in it on a table

Think of it like a puzzle. The larger barium ion needs more space between water molecules to fit comfortably. However, water molecules are held together by hydrogen bonds, and breaking these bonds to accommodate the barium ion requires energy. Therefore, it's more thermodynamically stable for barium carbonate to remain undissolved.

The Nature of the Carbonate Ion

The carbonate ion, with its three oxygen atoms, can form multiple hydrogen bonds with water. This makes it soluble in water. So, what happens when it's combined with the barium ion?

The barium ion, due to its high charge density, strongly attracts the lone pair electrons on the oxygen atoms in the carbonate ion. This attracts the carbonate ion towards the barium ion, forming a strong bond. This bond is so strong that it's difficult to break, making it hard for water to solvate the carbonate ion. As a result, barium carbonate remains insoluble in water.

Let’s Talk Carbonation!!!
Let’s Talk Carbonation!!!
Fun Science Kits & Experiments for Kids
Fun Science Kits & Experiments for Kids
Is Carbonated Water Better for My Teeth? - The Palisades Dentists
Is Carbonated Water Better for My Teeth? - The Palisades Dentists
Sodium acetate can freeze anything.
Sodium acetate can freeze anything.
Explainer: Ocean acidification
Explainer: Ocean acidification
Barium Nitrate & Sodium Sulphate - Sciencing
Barium Nitrate & Sodium Sulphate - Sciencing

The Solubility of Barium Carbonate in Other Solvents

But while barium carbonate remains insoluble in water, it can be dissolved in other solvents. This begs the question, what makes these solvents different?

Solvents like ethanol or other polar aprotic solvents can dissolve barium carbonate more easily than water. This is because these solvents can break the strong bond between the barium and carbonate ions without being held back by hydrogen bonding. Moreover, their polar aprotic nature allows them to solvate the carbonate and barium ions once they are separated.

Ethanol as a Solvent

Ethanol works differently compared to water. It can form hydrogen bonds with the carbonate ion without breaking apart due to its own intramolecular hydrogen bonding. This allows it to interact with the carbonyl oxygen atoms of the carbonate ion without disrupting its structure, making it a more suitable solvent for barium carbonate.

Sulfur Water Contaminants: Causes, Effects & Solutions
Sulfur Water Contaminants: Causes, Effects & Solutions
a diagram showing the parts of a bomb calorimeter
a diagram showing the parts of a bomb calorimeter
Are Carbonated Beverages Bad for You?
Are Carbonated Beverages Bad for You?

Moreover, the ethanol molecule's smaller size and the fact that it can form more hydrogen bonds than water allows it to solvate the carbonate ion more effectively. This reduces the favourable energetics of the water-based reaction, making the dissolution of barium carbonate in ethanol more feasible.

Understanding the insolubility of barium carbonate in water is a testament to the complex and fascinating world of chemistry. It's not just about big versus small molecules, but also about the intricacies of molecular interactions and the dynamics of solvent-solute bonding.

💬 Comments ↗ Share ★ Save
AD