Why Graphite Conducts Electricity, Diamond Doesn't
Graphite and diamond, both forms of carbon, exhibit starkly different electrical properties. While graphite is a highly conductive substance, diamond is a poor electrical insulator. Understanding this apparent contradiction begs the question: why does one of carbon's phases conduct electricity while the other doesn’t?
To unravel this enigma, we must delve into the unique lattice structures of these allotropes and their consequent bonding mechanisms. Let's commence our exploration by examining the electrical conductivity of graphite, and then contrast it with the insulating nature of diamond.
Electrical Conductivity in Graphite
Graphite, a soft, greyish-black solid, is composed of layered, two-dimensional sheets of carbon atoms. These sheets, known as graphene layers, are held together by weak interlayer forces, primarily London dispersion forces. The strong, covalent intralayer bonding within each graphene sheet forms delocalized pi (π) bonds, allowing for the movement of electrons throughout the sheet.
Free Electrons and Conduction
In graphite, one out of every three carbon atoms contributes a delocalized pi electron to a shared pool within the graphene layer. These electrons are free to move throughout the sheet, serving as the primary charge carriers. The overlap of molecular orbitals allows these electrons to essentially move without resistance, facilitating electrical conductivity along the basal plane of the sheets.
The Role of Layer Overlap
Despite the weak interlayer forces, a small overlap of electrons from adjacent graphene layers allows delocalized electrons to migrate between them. Consequently, the electrical conductivity through the c-axis, perpendicular to the layers, is significantly lower than within the layers themselves. However, for electron flow, graphite in its entirety, is still highly conductive compared to most materials.
Electrical Insulation in Diamond
Contrary to graphite, diamond exhibits exceptional insulating properties despite sharing the same element, carbon. Diamonds are three-dimensional, crystal lattices where each carbon atom forms strong, directional, and saturating covalent bonds with four neighboring carbon atoms. This tetrahedral structure, known as a diamond lattice, forms an efficient, rigid network that prevents any significant electron delocalization.
Stronger Bonding and Electron Pairing
The strong, directed nature of diamond's covalent bonds means that electrons are tied to specific, localized bond pairs. In contrast with graphite, the pi electrons in diamond are localized and paired with another electron of the same spin,)}\) thus, preventing their participation in delocalized bonding or as charge carriers. Consequently, diamonds exhibit a high electrical resistance and act as excellent insulators.
The Impact of Lattice Vibrations
At room temperature, the electrical resistance of diamonds decreases slightly due to an increment in lattice vibrations, which momentarily weaken the covalent bonds, and allow a limited number of electrons to become delocalized, aiding in charge transport. Nonetheless, this phenomenon is minor, and diamond's insulating properties remain dominating.
In essence, the profound discrepancy in electrical conductivities between graphite and diamond is chiefly attributed to their unique crystal structures. Graphite's two-dimensional layered structure and delocalized electrons permit electrons to move freely, facilitating conductivity. In contrast, diamond's three-dimensional, covalently-saturated structure localities electrons and precludes their free movement, resulting in exceptional electrical insulation.